Batting Cages in New Albany, IN
2 batting cages found
New Albany has a small but focused selection of batting cage facilities — two listings in total, both carrying perfect five-star ratings, which says something about the quality over quantity approach you’ll find here. Rather than large commercial complexes, what New Albany offers leans heavily toward coached, skill-development experiences, with both spots tagged for private lessons and youth-friendly environments. If you’re looking for a drop-in cage to swing tokens at a pitching machine, these venues skew more toward structured training than pure recreation.
The Lumber Yard stands out as the larger operation, with 76 reviews averaging a perfect 5.0. Reviewers consistently praise the cleanliness of the facility, the quality of coaching, and the organized programs — one parent noted they’ve been bringing their son for two years and found the coaches provide “detail lessons.” Another drove four hours specifically for the experience. The Lumber Yard offers rental bats and helmets, making it accessible even if you’re showing up without gear. Hollander Tom takes a more personal approach — a pitching-focused coach with a loyal following built over years. Reviewers describe Tom as “the best pitching coach in Kentuckiana,” and the decade-long relationships in the reviews reflect a deeply hands-on, mentor-style setup. He’s open weekday afternoons and most of the weekend, and walk-ins are welcome.
If you’re planning a visit to either spot in New Albany, keep in mind that both cater well to younger players, so weekend slots can fill up. Hollander Tom’s listed hours run afternoons on weekdays and broader windows on weekends — calling ahead is a smart move.
Map
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the best batting cage in New Albany, IN?
Both listed options — The Lumber Yard and Hollander Tom — hold perfect 5.0 ratings. The Lumber Yard has more reviews (76) and a full facility with rental equipment and organized programs, while Hollander Tom is especially praised for elite pitching coaching and a personal training style.
Are there indoor batting cages in New Albany?
The Lumber Yard is described by reviewers as a clean, full-featured facility, and its tags suggest an indoor setup with pitching machine access. It's best to contact each location directly to confirm indoor availability.
Which New Albany batting cages offer lessons?
Both The Lumber Yard and Hollander Tom offer private lessons. The Lumber Yard has coaches reviewers describe as providing detailed instruction, while Hollander Tom is specifically known as a top pitching coach in the Kentuckiana region.
Are there youth-friendly batting cages in New Albany?
Yes — both locations are tagged as youth-friendly. The Lumber Yard in particular has parents noting they bring their kids regularly for coached sessions, and Hollander Tom also works extensively with younger players.
Can I walk into a New Albany batting cage without a reservation?
Hollander Tom is tagged as walk-ins welcome, with hours running weekday afternoons from 3–9 PM and weekend hours starting at 9 AM. For The Lumber Yard, it's worth calling ahead since their programs can be in demand.